The Time Machine by H. G. Wells is probably the most famous of time travel novels, but you may be interested to know that it wasn’t the first – as is often incorrectly assumed. “The Clock that Went Backward” (Edward Page Mitchell) was published earlier in 1881, and even Wells’ own “The Chronic Argonauts” (published in 1888) predates the The Time Machine from 1895. Indeed, some argue that the The Time Machine is a sequel to the “Chronic Argonauts” although as yet this is not a commonly accepted consensus.
The open ending in The Time Machine lends itself well to a sequel so it’s unsurprising that many fans have chosen to retread Wells’ footsteps, and indeed, go to places as yet untrodden.
As a time travel enthusiast it is with a little shame that I must admit to having read only two such sequels.
Stephen Baxter’s The Time Ships is the “…official authorized sequel” (note American spelling to an English novel) and I suppose the traditional starting point for reading a sequel to The Time Machine.
In my review I gave The Time Ships a full 5 stars – as a stand-alone time travel novel it’s pretty good, but as a sequel to The Time Machine it fails miserably because there’s no consistency with the original.
For example, Baxter’s Time Traveller displays behaviour and shows characteristics in stark contrast to Wells’ depiction of him. Whereas Wells portrays him as a thoughtful character, curious and with high integrity and good motivation, Baxter’s main character is shallow and pretty much a prejudiced fool. We’re invited to think along in The Time Machine, to consider The Time Traveller’s thoughts and perhaps even to act on them. Conversely, we read The Time Ships to see what happens next.
And what happens next is predictable. There’s a mysterious visitor who comes to visit The Time Traveller, except that in time travel there is never any mystery. It’s you from the future. That’s no spoiler – it’s a time travel ontological ‘tool’ which has been used in a gazillion time travel books (e.g the excellent The Man who Folded Himself by David Gerrold) and will surely appear in a further gazillion.
Hooks from The Time Ships extending back to The Time Machine are stretched and contrived at best. This ranges from the writing style which sets off fairly similar to Wells’ style, but which gets diluted as we read further into the novel. We’ve already seen that the main character is completely different, but then there’s the Morlock companion he picks up along his travels in time. Nebogipfel. Seriously! Are we expected not to recognise that name from “The Chronic Argonauts”? It’s not a clever link because Nebogipfel the Morlock is not Dr. Moses Nebogipfel the time traveller.
So in short, The Time Ships is more like bad fan fiction than a true sequel to The Time Machine.
More recently I read (and was much more impressed with) Jaime Batista’s Epilogue: Time Machine Chronicles. Although I’ve already reviewed Epilogue very positively, this article takes on a different tack – how does it stand against the original (and why is it so much better than the authorised sequel)?
The thing which strikes me first about Epilogue is that it doesn’t start where The Time Machine finishes, but a little earlier. This means that there’s a certain overlapping of events and characters which meshes Epilogue seamlessly with The Time Machine.
So there’s a natural continuity, and I should also add here that the writing style is consistent with Wells’ throughout the entire novel.
Most remarkable though is how Jaime has managed to capture the real essence of The Time Traveller. We read about his thoughts (easy – being first person) but also his introspective musings about the thoughts that he has, and a willingness to admit that sometimes his initial ideas may not be correct.
It’s easy to empathise with him, and as a scientist myself I must admit to finding The Time Traveller somewhat as a role model in that he develops his ideas but remains open to modifying them. Oh yes, and building a time machine!
As well as the character, the general theme of Epilogue is truly nailed to a tee.
Whereas Baxter’s Time Traveller flits around seemingly without a purpose, in Epilogue there’s not only a clear goal, but also an eagerness to better understand the history of the future. For anyone who’s read The Time Machine (which is almost a statement on the then current political / social climate and its projected future) this thirst for understanding should be a pre-requisite for any sequel.
Ah yes, thirst. I read Epilogue a little under a year ago, but I remember very clearly a section where The Time Traveller suffered incredible thirst during one leg of his travels. It’s incredibly well written and makes it a very moving section – it must be because I remember it even now. The point is that as well as staying true to Wells’ writing style, Jaime injects his own.
In a way, Jaime – or indeed any sequel writer – faces a problem. How to take on the original ideas and concepts in an original novel and yet take them further. And I think this is done masterfully in Epilogue. For instance, there’s the mechanics of the time machine itself. In the original it’s pretty much black box, other than to say that time is a fourth dimension and with a twisting of the dimensions one can travel through time as one can travel through space.
Baxter deals with this in The Time Ships by stating that the twisting of the dimensions made the time traveller dizzy. But Jaime maintains the black box – and expands on the original idea:
“The time machine is a mechanical incarnation of a number of theories”
Now isn’t that more beautiful?! And there’s more: what happens if a fault develops in a time machine?
As you can tell, I love Epilogue, and the climax at the end is one of the most powerful conclusions to a novel I’ve ever read! I mentioned in my glowing review of Epilogue that it should be on every bookshelf (or ereader) which already holds a copy of The Time Machine. Yes – it’s that good, and if it’s not considered time travel blasphemy and I’m allowed to say it – I prefer it to the original!
As for sequels, if you’re torn between The Time Ships and Epilogue, go for Epilogue. It’s genuine, it’s original and it’s an excellent read!
There are countless other sequels to H. G. Wells’ classic The Time Machine and probably all the time in the world wouldn’t be enough to read all of them. But how do you feel about sequels to The Time Machine – what qualities do you look for in such a sequel? And I’d be very interested to know if you’ve read any other sequels that you’d recommend! Please feel free to leave a comment with your thoughts!
Paul

So many time-travel novels that are popular with kids these days are ones in series. Sometimes the books in the series are written by different authors. I have sometimes thought that it is a particular skill for the authors of the later books in the series to stay true to the tone of the first, and especiallly to have the character’s personality remain consistent. Apparently, all authors are not able to do this.
That’s a good point Susan, and I imagine one which is particularly important for younger readers who arguably need a greater degree of consistency between books in a series.
Admittedly these are the only sequels I’ve read by authors different to that of the original novel; I was amazed at the differences (in style) between them given that effectively they have the same foundation!