Big Finish Fridays: Doctor Who Audio Drama – The Hidden Realm

0
7850

As Lewis Carroll suggested, let’s begin at the beginning. David Llewellyn’s The Hidden Realm is very good.

The third Doctor and Jo Grant are captured perfectly. The writing knows them, and begins working at the favorite Big Finish trick: finding new depths of characterization in old, familiar characters. Tim Treloar continues to be inseparable from Pertwee. I’m uncertain how Katy Manning manages to summon up the youthful Jo Grant–of all the returning companions she, perhaps, has the widest gap to cross between how she sounded then and how she sounded now. But she successfully crosses it every time.

The writing is sold. We get a few new insights into Jo Grant. The plot, though nearly as time honored and worn as Guy Adams’, comes with some refreshing twists to keep it zipping along.

Nicholas Briggs’ direction is spot on.

It’s an excellent audio, and a fair new feather in Big Finish’s cap. A cap that, by now, is 90% feathers to 10% cap.

Carroll also suggested that when we come to the end, we stop. We’ve come to the end. If I stop there, I fear this would be an extremely unsatisfactory review.

So instead of talking about what the story did well, or what the story did poorly, or how this story somehow connects to the wider Doctor Who, or what this story means in context–things I am well accustomed to dither on about–let’s talk about this:

Three Ways The Hidden Realm Dashed James Bojaciuk’s Hopes and Dreams

Am I being a bit dramatic?

A bit.

Did the drama make your author smile?

Yes, too much.

These are things which do not harm the audio, but were aspects I was genuinely far more interested in than where Llewellyn took the production. Three things I wish had been given much more of a central focus.

Spoilers to follow.

1) 1970s Rural/Occult Horror

One of the most interesting developments in British horror is rural horror (sometimes called folk horror). A simple definition would be: “British rural horror suggests that witchcraft is well and alive in England’s countryside–not the friendly witchcraft of pop fiction and neo-paganism, but the dark, bloody witchcraft that even the Vikings would have feared, and turned the Romans on their heels.”

The most prominent example would be the The Wicker Man, but it was a genre that came into its own in the mid-1960s, had a huge burst of popularity in the early 1970s, and quickly died down thereafter.

This is an influence The Hidden Realm wears on its sleeve. It hits the required notes. Nature is not quite right. The locals are suspicious, only pretending to be friendly. Everyone is much too obsessed with old tales and rhymes. A carnival is the turning point, and where someone is converted.

This choice makes sense. The third Doctor era runs close to the rural horror fad, and many of their base constitutes are identical. The Daemons is virtually a teatime-telly friendly iteration of rural horror.

My problem is that this path wasn’t pursued far enough. It isn’t long before we’re back to robots and aliens, alternate dimensions and invasion. If we must have sci-fi in a story of this nature, I’d prefer it to be treated the same way The Daemons did–a bit of hand-waving to stay one step ahead of BBC obscenity rules.

Though given the fact Big Finish seems unafraid of naked mysticism, at least in small doses, I would have welcomed this story as a straight example of 70s rural horror.

2) Brain Hijackers and Past Doctors

The Doctor, at one point, is possessed by a Nazi (more on that in the next point). While struggling for control of his mind, the third Doctor exclaims “Oh my giddy aunt!”; Jo remarks that can’t be her Doctor, and the bit is over, swiftly moving on to a mental contest between the Doctor and the Nazi mind.

We missed out.

Though rarely mentioned, one of the longest-surviving bits of Virgin New Adventures canon is this: when a Doctor dies, he doesn’t permanently pass away. Instead, he sits in a “retirement home” in his own mind, occasionally giving advice to the current incarnation, or occasionally taking over the current incarnation in a true emergency.

Llewellyn seems to be playing with this trope, implying the first and second Doctor are also actively joining the third Doctor’s mind in battle for their body.

We don’t need more than that suggestion.

Listeners in the know realize what’s up. Unaware listeners get a giddy aunt reference, and smile.

I do wish that, instead of being treated so briefly, this was much more of a dramatic affair. That the battle for the Doctor’s body was more of a central aspect to the story. That we do actually see more of this battle for his body, as the Doctor’s three incarnations battle against the now dominant mind. We don’t even need to bring William Russell or Frazer Hines in, welcome as they would be.

3) Nazi Gold, and Where it Went

We’re briefly told that Nazis paid the alien to escape Nazi Germany, in the war’s dying days, by placing their minds in new bodies. We had been previously told the alien only accepts payments in gold.

Therefore, the obvious implication is that all the missing Nazi gold was paid to the alien.

While I appreciate a bit of fridge logic, and always love a story that makes the audience have to think, this is such an interesting story hook that I would’ve loved to see it be a major facet of the story.

You can purchase The Third Doctor Adventures: Volume 02 (which includes The Hidden Realm) from BigFinish.com.

James Bojaciuk

James Bojaciuk

As a child, I once spent several weeks trying to build a time machine. That should tell you just about everything. I'm also CEO Duobus of 18thWall Productions, a publishing house dedicated to fantasy, mystery, and sci-fi. All that and he's co-host of The Raconteur Roundtable podcast, and an author whose stories and essays have appeared all across the weird and pulp world.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here