Bow Ties Are Cool And Other Thoughts About The Eleventh Doctor 

0
8403

Matt Smith entered the TARDIS with one strike already against him.

He wasn’t David Tennant.

As unfair as it was for me to judge him for that, for most of his run, I did. I was so in love with his predecessor that The Eleventh Doctor just annoyed me.

Looking back on his run, a couple of years after Smith left the TARIDS, I realized that he does have a lot of fun moments.

Like this one.

My biggest problem with Eleven is how he was written. In moments like this where Matt was allowed to be a giant kid who just happens to get to run around space and time to have adventures he had the potential to be the greatest Doctor to walk into the TARDIS.

Unfortunately, more often than not he was written to be an old man with a young face and boy could he brood.

Don’t get me wrong here, The Doctor is old and he does deserve moments to brood. But that wasn’t where Matt Smith shone and as other show runners have done in the past, they should have catered his run to him. After all, when they more or less let a Doctor play himself, that’s when he shines.

Example, David Tennant.

Matt Smith took to the TARDIS in the Eleventh Hour. It was the first of a couple of plays made throughout his run on him being the Eleventh incarnation.

My favorite being from the beginning of his final season as The Doctor.

Matt Smith took charge of the TARDIS for three seasons and to be honest, they had their ups and downs.

His first companions, Rory and Amy Pond (technically it was Williams but Rory never won that fight) stayed with him until half-way through his final season when they left.

After the Ponds left, Eleven was joined by Clara, someone we’d met a few times off and on. Jenna Coleman would then stay on as Clara through his regeneration before leaving last season.

Clara has become known as The Impossible Girl because she jumped in and out of The Doctor’s time stream to save him in The Name Of The Doctor, Eleven’s last regular episode. Theoretically, according to that episode, due to this incident, versions of Clara exist all through his past, present, and future.

Too, also hypothetically, they voided that out in Eleven’s regeneration episode. Depends on who you talk to.

Timey Whimey and all that.


I would be remiss if I didn’t mention one of my favorite Eleven moments featuring Stormagedon, Dark Lord Of All.

He also speaks horse.

Seriously, they should have given him a child companion and let them have fun. Because there were moments, like this one, like several others where I could see where he could have become my favorite Doctor. But they get buried under a lot of stuff that didn’t need to be there, didn’t fit Matt Smith and was instead forced upon him.

Matt Smith holds the prestigious title of being the current Doctor during the 50th Anniversary special. He was joined by John Hurt and David Tennant (swoon) for the adventure and our first and only glimpse into The Time War.


For a Doctor who I still have mixed emotions about, I was a bit disappointed with how the show chose to send him off. I don’t think he was given the exit he deserved, but he did have one moment, where he did get me to think that maybe I would miss him.

The bit near the end when he takes off the bow tie. I’d wondered how they’d handled it.

Because if you learn nothing else about The Eleventh Doctor, learn this. In his eyes, there was nothing cooler than the bow tie he proudly wore. He defended that thing the entire course of his run.

A couple years have passed since Eleven left the TARDIS. I honestly didn’t expect to miss him as much as I do. I guess that’s the thing about Doctor Who. Even if the Doctor who’s in the TARDIS isn’t your favorite, he’s still The Doctor.

And you miss him when he goes.

Each face, each quirk, each has their own way of seeing the universe.

I’ll never understand his fascination with bow ties or his love of fish fingers and custard, but I have grown to appreciate the Eleventh Doctor.

Mary Helen Norris
Mary Helen first got hooked on time travel as a young girl watching the Back To The Future Movies. Since then, she has snagged Craig's time machine and gone back to see the Beatles as well as a few other stops. When she's not patrolling the space/time continuum, she's reading, writing, and learning something new.
Mary Helen Norris
Mary Helen Norris
maryhelen@timetravelnexus.com

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here