The sound of a speeding train and a blasting whistle are followed by the announcer (Maurice Tarplin), in a voice as creepy as Vincent Price, welcoming us to another edition of the mystery and suspense show, Mysterious Traveler.
Unlike last month’s episode, which quantum leaped us to the future, this one is a more conventional trip back in time. And not only that, the story revolves around an effort to stop Lincoln’s assassination, pretty high on the list of cliched time travel plots guaranteed to fail.
The Man Who Tried to Save Lincoln, recorded on February 7, 1950, was written by Robert A. Arthur, who penned last month’s forward-leaping episode Operation Tomorrow. It also stars the same actors as the previous show in almost identical roles–Ralph Bell (triple threat stage/screen/radio actor) as the physics professor who invents a time machine and child-star-turned-adult-voice-actor Leon Janney as the young adventurer eager to travel in time.
We open in a laboratory at a small college in Pennsylvania where heavy-set, middle-aged Professor Hodges (Bell) is tinkering with a maze of electronic apparatus (apparatii?). He’s murmuring, trying to get his thingamajig machine to jump back in time more than 40 years. He’s interrupted by the jingle of the the telephone.

Mrs. Erskine (Lesley Woods, long-time radio/TV soap actress) is on the other end of the line. In an accent that’s a cross between Brooklyn and Birmingham, she chides Hodges for being late to her tea. He’s suitably chastised, but what’s an absent-minded professor to do?
Mrs. Erskine convinces him to head on over to her little bitty place, where she introduces him to Tom Morrison (Janney), author of If Lincoln Had Lived, then abandons them to attend to her other guests. The men chuckle patronizingly then get down to business.

“Tell me what would’ve happened if Lincoln had lived?” the professor (and a million-and-one authors of alternative history) asks. Tom’s ready with the answers—the recovery would’ve been faster, the US would’ve taken a more active role as a world leader, and there would’ve been no post-war bitterness. I’m with him on the first two points, but the latter? Seems unlikely.
The prof, impressed, tells Tom he’s just the man he’s been looking for to help with his latest experiment. “Explain,” Tom demands, but Hodges doesn’t. He drops a teaser instead. “Tom, how’d you like to step back in time to that fatal night in April 1865…and save Abraham Lincoln’s life?”
Dramatic organ music rolls up and segues to the next scene, where we hear coos and squeaks that sound like an invasion of Tribbles but are really the professor’s machine booting up. Tom is underwhelmed by its appearance. “It’s no DeLorean,” the prof says, “but it’ll do the job.” And that job isn’t to ferry a person back and forth in time, it’s to… Well, here’s where the explanation gets less timey-wimey and more metaphysical.
The professor’s version of time travel channels the book Time After Time and the book/movie Somewhere in Time. With the machine focused on a particular person at a particular date in history, one can travel there mentally, rather than physically. Tom translates for us non-quantum-physicists in the crowd, “You mean my brain pattern will be impressed on someone living in the past? I can think with their mind and move about in their body?”
Yup, Professor Hodges says, but there’s a catch. “Suppose you find your mind inside the brain of a very strong-willed individual. You will probably be helpless and unable to influence his actions,” he explains, with absolutely no foreshadowing whatsoever.
Hodges suggests he take the time machine out for a spin. The professor proposes sending Tom back to 1912, to the city library, conveniently located across the street. Also, conveniently, where Tom’s mother was a librarian—and where Tom’s parents met. Tom loves the idea. “Dad was so bowled over when he met mom, he forgot to take the book he was checking out.”
“I know,” Hodges says, with no explanation how. He produces the book—The Life of Lincoln—and the library card Tom’s dad forgot to fill out. My stalker alert goes off, but Tom’s just gee whizzes at this amazing bit of history. “I know it’s possible to send your brain pattern back in time,” the prof says (again, how?), “but is it possible to change what happened?” He suggests they find out by having Tom sign the un-signed library card.
A bit more back and forth with Tom repeating every blooming thing the professor says, and we finally get to the time travel portion of the episode. Hodges fire up the Tribbles—er—the time machine and Tom concentrates on the date and time until…

“Mr. Morrison are you ill?” a kindly female voice asks. Tom’s not ill, he’s flustered and flummoxed and that’s because he’s not himself, he’s Henry, his dad, and only semi-aware of Tom floating around inside his brain. Gotta admit, it’s a cool concept, and well-executed.
Smooth dude “Henry” invites Miss Andrews to lunch. She agrees, but before they can go, he’s compelled by something, a voice in his head, perhaps, telling him to sign the card for the book he’s checking out. Tom’s personality pushes through, forcing Henry to sign “Tom” before he reasserts his personality and crosses out the name, writing his own. Then he passes out.

Tom awakens in the laboratory with Professor Hodges hovering over him, demanding to know what happened. Success, I guess, since Tom remembers being in the library, staring at his own mother as a young woman. Success in all ways—Hodges produces the signed card with both Tom’s name and his father’s. Tom’s stunned. He really did travel in time.
Professor Hodges is beyond giddy, promising to send Tom back further, so he can hear Lincoln deliver the Gettysburg address. And that’s just what he does in the next scene, dropping Tom in the brain of Jesse Evans, a farmer from Gettysburg.
Tom’s more with it than he was inside his dad’s consciousness. He listens in awe as Lincoln, sounding like a drunken zombie, delivers his famous speech. “I saw him!” Tom enthuses when he awakens. “I saw Lincoln! Jesse Evans was such a simple fellow I could live in his mind for thirty minutes and hear the whole speech.”

Hodges doesn’t hear the words “simple fellow” or maybe he’s too excited to pay attention. He tells Tom he’s ready to send him back to prevent Lincoln’s assassination. The two make plans to go to DC and in the next scene, they’re all set up inside the theater. How they did that with a hundred tours going through a day I’ll never know.
Tom preps to mind-travel, while waxing poetic about feeling Lincoln’s strong presence in the theater—and also John Wilkes Booth’s. He recounts the events of the fatal night in detail, describing every step Booth took, past the ticket taker, up the stairs, and bypassing Lincoln’s armed guard, who’d stepped away from his post to watch the play.
For the audience’s benefit, Professor Hodges repeats that Tom’s ability to alter/observe historic events depends on the type of mind he inhabits. If he should pop into the brain of a strong-willed person, Tom might not be able to control him. Hodges recommends Tom aim to land in the ticket-taker’s brain, since the man knew Booth and also because ticket-takers aren’t known for their “great mental achievements.” Well! On behalf of ticket-takers worldwide, I would like to lodge a protest.

The professor fires up the machine and Tom’s off to April 13, 1865. Poor simple fellow. He should’ve known Mother Time and Father Fate don’t like to play fair. I mean, where’s the fun in that?
He quantum leaps into someone’s brain, but it’s not the ticket-taker. Tom knows where he is, Ford’s Theater, and when, the night of the assassination, but he’s a bit fuzzy on everything else. He only knows that there’s a gun in his coat pocket and he’s angry. Really angry. At Lincoln.
It’s not long before Tom realizes whose brain he’s stuck in—the very strong-willed John Wilkes Booth.
“Excuse me,” he says to the ticket-taker. “I must go inside the theater. I have a very important engagement to keep. A matter of life and death.”
Dramatic music swells. The end.
This episode was as exposition heavy as the previous episode I recapped, and the twist was evident a mile away. But the acting was topnotch, and the tense pacing made it work. And it left me dying to know what happened to poor Tom. Was his consciousness trapped in Booth’s brain? Or did he return to the professor in the present, wracked with guilt for not only failing to stop the assassination, but also being a party to it?
I guess if a story leaves you wanting more when it’s done, the writer has done their job.



