It’s that time of year again where I keep an eye on a handful of lists (and make a couple of my own) to see what television lives to see another season and what I’m saying goodbye to.
A few weeks ago, I already made note of my biggest farewell, ABC’s Time After Time which was cancelled after only five episodes.
Let’s break it down show by show (though in one case I am going to group them together.
- Arrowverse Shows (The Arrow, Flash, DC’s Legends of Tomorrow, and Supergirl)

Yes, I did group these four together. They are also the first to be renewed in CW’s tradition of doing a series of early renewals in January. Unlike a lot of the shows airing, their decisions were made before their finales were filmed so they could plan accordingly.
Here’s some of my predictions, keeping in mind that finales for three of the four haven’t aired yet.
a. The Arrow
Sorry, Arrow fans. I think this is the weak link of the set these days. I will make the disclaimer that this is the one of the four I don’t watch but from what I’ve heard from some people watching it, it’s started to circle the drain.
They could prove me wrong but there could be a chance that this time next year, the Arrowverse goes down to three again (unless another one is added, a possibility). In fact, I’d love for them to do it.
b. The Flash
With the announcement that the big bad of next season isn’t a Speedster, The Flash might have just saved themselves from growing stale. That was becoming their biggest problem and had started to put them in a rut.
There are some wildcards that keep me from making a full prediction on this one until the finale airs in a couple of weeks and we see the results of the paradox we’ve been in the entire second half of the season.
So, I’ll have to do a followup post later on this.
I will admit, I’ve found myself greatly enjoying The Flash this season. Besides the musical episode (I cannot sing its praises enough), it’s just become a pit of temporal madness that leaves me trying to solve it’s complexities.
And I can’t help but love it.
c. Supergirl
Making the move from CBS to The CW did wonders for Supergirl. In a sense, this was another first season for her as The CW got it’s sea legs with The Girl of Steel and figured her out.
That being said, I have high hopes for her third season as the CW really starts playing with her.
d. DC’s Legends Of Tomorrow
First off, if anyone at The CW is reading this, can this show get longer seasons like the rest of its friends in the Arrowverse?
Please?
Pretty please?
Secondly, I’m curious how they’re going to resolve some issues that are bleeding over into the new season. In true CW fashion, I expect the cliffhanger to be resolved within the first few episodes and the fallout is what we face in the next season.
2. Making History
Never watched. Never really plan to. Wasn’t surprised this got cancelled. When you waste your chance to do a time travel show and focus on getting laughs instead of historical accuracy…
At least, that’s the impression I got from the trailer and it was enough for me to have absolutely no interest in watching.
3. Frequency

For a network that has a lot of time travel going on, they dropped the ball with this one. I started to lose interest because this wasn’t time travel, it was a giant universe imploding paradox that got worse and worse as time went on.
That’s why it didn’t work. It didn’t make sense, it’s rules of time alteration didn’t work, and other aspects of the show couldn’t compensate for that brokenness.
This one hung in an odd limbo for months (it wasn’t mentioned in the initial CW announcement in January). Most people (including us here at the Nexus) believed it was cancelled. The lead actress even jumped ship to another show.
Finally, the official cancellation came.
4. Time After Time

My biggest disappointment of the cancellation season. Ratings weren’t in the favor of this show because it wasn’t the time travel, it wasn’t the acting, and it certainly wasn’t the writing.
Best case scenario, they release some of the episodes they filmed and at least let us have that. Sadly, I don’t think I’ll even get that and see a whole season of this show.
Yes, I know the show is based off of the book and I grabbed a copy to read. I just wish the show had been given a chance.
5. Timeless

I intentionally saved this one for last because the cancellation order came last Wednesday or Thursday and I was disappointed. Any show that spends the amount of time they did on maintaining historical accuracy should get a second season.
It seemed like all the new time travel television shows were a bust.
Then, Saturday morning while I was wandering around a local Harry Potter festival, I get a message from James Bojaciuk saying it had been renewed.
That rarely happens, a show getting renewed after it received the cancellation order. But against all odds, Timeless is coming back for a 10 episode season sometime in 2018.
Honestly, from what I’ve heard it’s thanks to the dedicated fans of the show. They made their voices heard when it was cancelled and NBC found a way to make it happen. Perhaps there is the true power of social media (that and getting someone a year’s supplies of free nuggets from Wendy’s by breaking a world record in the process).
This is one I fell behind on, after all there’s a lot on television these days and I do maintain a couple not-sci-fi shows for the sake of being well-rounded. And I look forward to catching up and seeing what’s in store for it.
As we wrap up, here’s a bonus item to talk about.
Make sure you watch the new season of 12 Monkeys on SyFy!
Friday, Saturday, and Sunday night the entire season will air back to back to back. It looks like it’s also going to be commercial free judging by the air times.
They’ve already gotten renewed for another season which takes the pressure off this experiment. I am curious to see how it plays off.
